P.J. Williams
SMU
Scouting Report

Williams is one of the most tantalizing athletic packages at offensive tackle in this cycle — a former basketball standout who moves like a man 40 pounds lighter, with an explosive kick step that creates immediate width and depth off the snap. The physical tools scream Day 2 upside, but the tape tells a more complicated story: underdeveloped hand usage, inconsistent pad level, and set angles that invite speed-to-power conversions from NFL-caliber rushers. His 2025 performance against Miami's Rueben Bain Jr. showed he can compete against elite talent when locked in, but the 12-penalty season in 2024 and periodic lapses in technique suggest a player who still wins more on instinct than process. The return to school for 2026 is the smart play — another year of reps could transform him from a developmental Day 3 flyer into a legitimate top-75 pick if the technical refinement catches up to the physical gifts.

Strengths
Weaknesses
Pro ComparisonMatt Pryor (early career)

Similar athletic profile to body type ratio — a massive mover with legitimate tackle length who started his career winning on physical gifts rather than refined technique, needing multiple years of NFL coaching to become a reliable starter.

Go deeper on P.J. Williams
Interactive trait radar, scheme fit analysis, combine percentiles, and AI mock draft projections.
Open Big Board Lab